Ketchup Tasting Party

Homemade Ketchups ready to be tasted (The winner was Ketchup A)

Homemade Ketchups ready to be tasted (The winner was Ketchup A)

About this time last year I made my first homemade ketchup. Shortly afterwards, the National Post mentioned my ketchup & then they tasted my ketchup compared to two other recipes. I thought this was a fabulous idea! A Ketchup Tasting Party. I mean, who doesn’t love French fries and onion rings. And, an excuse to eat them while doing “research” about best tasting ketchup, I’m all over it!

So, I decided to taste the Jamie Oliver ketchup that the National Post made. I wanted a super easy ketchup made from tomato paste. I wanted to remake the one I made last year from the Joy of Cooking. Heinz should be in there, I mean it is the best-selling ketchup. And, then I came across another recipe where they roasted the tomatoes in the oven (this reminds me of my salsa).

blind taste testing of ketchup with French fries and onion rings

A: the winner! Made with tomato paste
B: roasted tomato ketchup
C: Heinz
D: Joy of Cooking
E: Jamie Oliver’s

I made it a blind taste test so that no one would feel too persuaded by any names associated with the various ketchups. We tasted with French friends and onion rings. I even made up “Tasting Notes Sheets” so that we could track our thoughts about each as we tasted. There was much tasting and discussing. It was great fun! Then, we had burgers (beef for the meat eaters and homemade veggie patties for the veggies) with the winning ketchup.

Now, as a bit of a confession, I’ve never been a big fan of ketchup. It’s always seemed too sweet and too boring to me. I’d rather have plain French fries or even better, with ranch dressing.

tasting ketchup with French friend and onion rings

To my surprise, there was a clear winner: ketchup A the ketchup made with canned tomato paste! Everyone gave it the highest ranking, with comments like thick, good texture, tangy, complex, yum, perfect appearance, dark red color, and Perfect! And, it was the easiest and quickest one to make. I’m so excited that it was super easy and can be made any time of year!

Unfortunately, there was one that was a disaster (ketchup B): the one made with roasted tomatoes. I followed the instructions, but 3 hours in the oven didn’t produce nice little roasted tomatoes, it produced lumps of coal. I made another batch of roasted tomatoes following my roasted tomato salsa directions, then I followed the rest of the ketchup instructions. But, in the end, this ketchup came in last place with comments like looks like salsa, too chunky, and peppery.

Heinz (ketchup C) did fairly well in the tasting. Placing either 2nd of 3rd in the voting. I think people who like ketchup, appreciate this flavor because it’s what they grew up with. Comments like shiny, a little runny, vinegary, light color, one-dimensional, and chemical tasting were made.

Jamie Oliver’s recipe (ketchup E) came in second place with comments like good-looking, sweet, like BBQ sauce, dark and appealing, deep rich flavor but closer to BBQ sauce than ketchup, and too tangy. So, I think I’d add a tablespoon or so of chili powder, ¼ cup of molasses, and 2 tablespoons of Worcestershire sauce and see if that makes it super BBQ sauce.

And the Joy of Cooking ketchup (ketchup D) placed 3rd with comments like nice color, high in nutmeg flavor, good texture, sweet, and appealing.

It was great fun! :) And, I’m so glad we had the opportunity to play with our food (adapted recipes are below the pictures)!

French fries and onion rings ready to be dunked in ketchup!

French fries and onion rings ready to be dunked in ketchup!

Tomato Paste Ketchup: easy, quick, and great flavor

Tomato Paste Ketchup: easy, quick, and great flavor

Tomato Paste Ketchup
Ketchup A The Winner!!!
Write a review
429 calories
107 g
0 g
1 g
8 g
0 g
384 g
1878 g
95 g
0 g
0 g
Nutrition Facts
Serving Size
Amount Per Serving
Calories 429
Calories from Fat 7
% Daily Value *
Total Fat 1g
Saturated Fat 0g
Trans Fat 0g
Polyunsaturated Fat 0g
Monounsaturated Fat 0g
Cholesterol 0mg
Sodium 1878mg
Total Carbohydrates 107g
Dietary Fiber 7g
Sugars 95g
Protein 8g
Vitamin A
Vitamin C
* Percent Daily Values are based on a 2,000 calorie diet. Your Daily Values may be higher or lower depending on your calorie needs.
  1. 1 (6 ounce) can tomato paste
  2. ¼ cup mild honey
  3. ¼ cup white vinegar
  4. ¼ cup water
  5. 1 teaspoon brown sugar
  6. ¾ teaspoon salt
  7. ¼ teaspoon onion powder
  8. 1/8 teaspoon garlic powder
  1. Combine all the ingredients in a medium saucepan over medium heat; whisk until smooth. Bring to a boil, reduce heat to low and simmer for 10-15 minutes, stirring often. Remove from heat, and allow to cool. Chill and store refrigerated in a covered container.
Adapted from
Adapted from
Life Currents
If you like what you see, please click the yum button: Yum

Jamie Oliver's ketchup, a bit more like BBQ sauce than ketchup, but really tasty

All the veggies cooking down for Jamie Oliver’s ketchup. This one was a bit more like BBQ sauce than ketchup, but really tasty

Jamie Oliver’s ketchup
Adapted from

1 ½ red onions, peeled and roughly chopped
1 stick celery, trimmed and roughly chopped
1 tablespoon olive oil
2 garlic cloves, peeled and sliced
½ fresh red chili, deseeded and finely chopped (I used a Hungarian pepper)
1 bunch fresh basil, leaves picked, stalks chopped, divided use
1 tablespoon coriander seeds
2 whole cloves
Sea salt
1 teaspoon freshly ground black pepper
1 pound Roma tomatoes, halved
1 pound canned crushed tomatoes
¾ cup red wine vinegar
1/3 cup brown sugar

Place all the vegetables in a large heavy-bottomed saucepan with a big splash of olive oil and garlic, chili, basil stalks, coriander seeds and cloves. Season with pepper and a good pinch of salt.

Cook gently over low heat for 10 to 15 minutes until softened, stirring every so often. Add all the tomatoes and 1 1/2 cups of cold water. Bring to the boil and simmer gently until the sauce reduces by half, about 30 minutes.

Add the basil leaves, then blend the sauce in a Food Processor or blender and push it through a fine mesh sieve, to make it smooth and shiny. Put the sauce into a clean pan and add the vinegar and the sugar. Place the sauce over medium-heat and simmer until it reduces and thickens to the consistency of tomato ketchup. Taste for salt and pepper.

Spoon the ketchup through a sterilized funnel into sterilized bottles, then seal tightly and place in a cool dark place or the refrigerator until needed – it should keep for up to 6 months.

If you’d like to can/preserve ketchup, please follow the instructions from the USDA’s National Center for Home Food Preservation or the official site from the makers of Ball jars.

Farmer's market bounty for homemade ketchups

I went to the Farmer’s market to get all of the veggies for the homemade ketchups

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...


  1. says

    Shared on these tasty sites:

  2. says

    I sure am glad that you did all that work for us. I can’t wait to taste the winner, it looks awesome! Hope you have a great week and thank you so much for sharing with Full Plate Thursday.
    Come Back Soon!
    Miz Helen

  3. says

    I absolutely love this idea. Personally this sounds way more delicious to me than the beer tasting parties some friends of mine have.

    I’m pretty sure Malcolm Gladwell has a piece in one of his books about how a couple of generations ago there was (for the most part in the US) just basic ketchup and basic mustard. Then there was a big mustard rush around the time when the “Pardon me, do you have any Grey Poupon” commercials were popular. Now, it seems like a lot of grocery stores have entire aisles dedicated to a gazillion types of mustards (hey – I think they’re all tasty), but for whatever reason varieties of ketchup never really took off, and people have tried. Seems like at the end of the day most people wanted their ketchup to stay the standard ketchup taste.

    On the other hand, I love variety (I always say it’s the spice of life) and am definitely down with more variety in my ketchup.

  4. says

    Wow, this Ketchup looks delicious! Thanks so much for linking up to Creative Thursday. Can’t wait to see what you share this week! Have a wonderful week.

  5. jshallow01 says

    I think this would be such a fun idea for a MNO or a couples party. We could each make our own ketchup and also bring a tray of items to dip in it. I so want to do this!


Leave a Reply